New Carlisle Homes under $250,000

Welcome to New Carlisle, Ohio – a charming city nestled in the heart of Clark County, where small-town charm meets modern convenience. Known for its friendly atmosphere and strong community spirit, New Carlisle is an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone looking to enjoy a peaceful lifestyle without sacrificing access to urban amenities.

With a rich history that dates back to the early 19th century, New Carlisle boasts a unique blend of historical architecture and contemporary developments. Residents enjoy a variety of local parks, recreational facilities, and community events that foster a sense of belonging. The city’s vibrant downtown area is dotted with quaint shops, delightful eateries, and essential services, making it easy to enjoy everything this lovely city has to offer.

For those seeking affordable housing options, New Carlisle shines with an impressive selection of homes priced under $250,000. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer or looking to downsize, the market here offers a diverse range of properties, from cozy single-family homes to charming bungalows. These affordable options make it easier than ever to find your dream home in a welcoming community.

Living in New Carlisle means enjoying the tranquility of suburban life while being just a short drive away from the bustling cities of Dayton and Springfield. With its affordable housing, strong community ties, and beautiful surroundings, New Carlisle is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. Come explore the possibilities and find your perfect home in this delightful Ohio city!

Newest New Carlisle Homes under $250,000

$165,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 970229 MLS ⋅ Gary L Gould

Welcome to 234 Prentice Dr. in New Carlisle. Don't miss your opportunity to explore homeownership in this nice move in ready ranch style home. Features include 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, a large living room with vaulted ceiling and paddle fan and plenty of windows outfitted with curtains and rods. Enjoy the updated kitchen with ample counter space, the newly remodeled bathroom with tub enclosure, laminate plank flooring throughout the house and fresh paint. Outside you will appreciate the covered front porch, quiet private backyard with privacy fencing all around and a spacious 2-car detached garage with plenty of parking space. New roof on house just 1 year old, garage roof is 5 years old and blacktop driveway just 4 months old. Move in and start enjoying the work that the seller has already done for you. Close to shopping, dining, I-70, I-675, St. Rt. 235 and the new Buc-ee's Travel Center.

234 Prentice Drive, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Gary L Gould and Keller Williams Home Town Rlty

$164,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 969943 MLS ⋅ Michelle Staas

This charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers an inviting open floor plan that seamlessly connects the kitchen and living room—perfect for modern living and entertaining. The bright and airy interior features vaulted ceilings, neutral-toned walls, and beautiful bay windows that flood the space with natural light throughout the day. The kitchen includes a range, dishwasher, and refrigerator, all of which convey with the home. Thoughtful updates include a renovated laundry room with custom cabinetry for enhanced storage and organization. A new air conditioning unit was installed in 2022 and updated furnace heating elements replaced in winter 2025–2026 for reliable year-round comfort. The home also includes a washer and dryer, built-in bookshelves, and curtains. Step outside to discover a generous yard graced by a magnificent established tree that provides abundant shade during warmer months —a true standout feature that adds character and charm to the outdoor space. Additional conveniences include an outdoor storage shed for lawn equipment and tools. Located in a well-maintained neighborhood with established landscaping, this home combines practical improvements, comfortable living spaces, and delightful outdoor appeal, making it a wonderful opportunity for your next chapter.

1006 N Scott Street, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Michelle Staas and CENTURY 21 The Gene Group

$205,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 969876 MLS ⋅ Mike Seagraves

The one-story single-family home offers a balanced approach to modern living. Featuring three bedrooms and one full bathroom, the residence provides a solid foundation for daily routines. Spanning 1215 square feet of living area, the layout offers a dedicated setting for relaxation and activities. Outside, the property features a fence and a patio on a lot measuring 0.18 acres. The patio invites quiet moments outdoors, while the fence provides a sense of definition to the yard. Updates include but are not limited to Remodeled bathroom, new hot water heater, remodeled kitchen, newer carpet. Located in New Carlisle, Ohio, this home combines functional design with outdoor space.

1248 Styer Drive, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Mike Seagraves and RE/MAX Alliance Realty

$250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 969379 MLS ⋅ Chrissie Pennington

Completely renovated and ready to shine! This beautiful 3-bedroom home in the Tecumseh School District has been updated from top to bottom, so you can move right in and enjoy it without the renovation headaches. The bright front living room features a large window that fills the space with natural light, while the gorgeous new kitchen is sure to be a favorite with brand-new cabinets, granite countertops, new appliances, and a charming breakfast nook. Need more space? The bonus room offers plenty of flexibility and could easily be used as a formal dining room, second living area, office, or whatever fits your lifestyle—and with a brand-new glass sliding door, it opens directly to the large backyard. You'll also find 3 bedrooms, a full bath, and a convenient half bath. The updates go well beyond the cosmetics, with new windows, flooring, paint, lighting, roof, and updates to the plumbing, HVAC, and electrical. Outside, the corner lot gives you plenty of room to spread out, with a large backyard, concrete driveway, and a 2-car garage. Beautifully updated, bright, functional, and ready for its next chapter—this one is definitely worth a look!

1013 W Lake Avenue, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Chrissie Pennington and Glasshouse Realty Group

$155,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 969440 MLS ⋅ KD ` Nave

Welcome home to this completely refreshed one-level ranch offering comfortable living and a convenient location! The inviting main living area features an open floor plan, creating an easy flow for everyday living and entertaining. With three bedrooms and thoughtful updates throughout, this home is truly move-in ready. Central air has been added for year-round comfort. Outside, enjoy a welcoming front porch and a great yard with a private backyard--perfect for relaxing or enjoying time outdoors. Conveniently located close to shopping, dining, and everyday amenities, and situated within the Tecumseh School District. This charming ranch is ready for its next owner to call it home!

800 N Scott Street, New Carlisle

Courtesy of KD ` Nave and Glasshouse Realty Group

$159,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 969172 MLS ⋅ Natalie M Jackson

Delightful, cozy home in New Carlisle with 816 sq ft, 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, kitchen, large living room and an extra room that can be a dining room, office or whatever you want. Completely fenced backyard with shed, 1 car attached garage and numerous updates. New furnace and AC in 2017, new roof in 2022, a few new windows, newer water heater and new flooring. Make this adorable home yours!

108 Funston Avenue, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Natalie M Jackson and Mumma Realty

$224,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 968965 MLS ⋅ Ronald L Grout

Nestled along the outskirts of New Carlisle, this early-1900s Cape Cod is full of character and lovingly maintained by the same owners for over 40 years. Updates include a newer HVAC system, new water heater, vinyl replacement windows, and dimensional roofing, while original charm remains with natural woodwork, spacious rooms, and hardwood floors (covered by existing carpeting). Enjoy a large living room with banister staircase, a main-level bonus room for office/play space, a roomy formal dining area, and an updated kitchen with Corian countertops, center island, and stainless appliances (including gas range and built-in dishwasher). The enclosed rear patio now serves as the main-level laundry, with quick access to the rear sundeck and backyard, plus a full main-level bath. Upstairs offers two privately located bedrooms with excellent closet space. The larger bedroom includes a connecting bath with jetted tub and an adjacent 10x10 bonus area (nursery, sitting area, or secondary office). The finish ed lower level adds a family room, concealed storage, and a flex room that can function as a 3rd bedroom. Outside, you’ll find a newer concrete driveway, a 2-car detached garage, and a 16x20 concrete block outbuilding with full electric and lofted storage—perfect for a workshop, she shed, man cave, or garden storage. With strong curb appeal from retaining walls and a covered front porch, this home is clean, well maintained, and priced right—

612 W Madison Street, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Ronald L Grout and BHHS Professional Realty

$157,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 968665 MLS ⋅ Ronald L Grout

Setting on a corner lot with mature trees, this inviting three-bedroom, one-bath home offers a covered front porch that’s perfect for entertaining. Inside, you’ll find an open-concept living room and plenty of updates, including a roof from 2018, windows from 2016, a furnace from 2021, and sewer from the home to the curb in 2024. The detached garage measures 16’ x 22’ and provides ample storage, along with off-street parking and an asphalt driveway. Convenient entrances include both a front door and a side door. The home also appears to have been cared for by the same owner for over 60 years. This property is priced to move with just a little TLC—so you’ll likely gain equity right away. While there are no known defects, the home is being sold as-is, and immediate occupancy is available. Don’t wait—schedule your tour today, as this one won’t last long.

300 Fenwick Drive, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Ronald L Grout and BHHS Professional Realty

$190,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 968747 MLS ⋅ Mike Kelly

Welcome to Silverlake Estates! This updated 3 bedroom, 1 bath ranch offers approximately 1,250 sq ft of comfortable living space in one of New Carlisle’s established neighborhoods. Built in 1972, this home features an open concept layout that creates a bright, welcoming atmosphere with great flow for everyday living, entertaining, and family gathering. The spacious kitchen serves as the heart of the home, featuring a center island with plenty of prep space, casual seating, and room to gather. The connected living area is anchored by a large, operational wood-burning fireplace that provides warmth, character, and the perfect setting for cozy evenings at home. Major renovations and improvements have already been completed, including updates to all major mechanical systems within the last 6 years. The heavy lifting has been done, giving you peace of mind while leaving just a few minor cosmetic, finishing touches to make the home your own. Outside, you’ll find a 2+ car garage with ample space for vehicles, storage, hobbies, or a workshop. The fully privacy fenced backyard is designed for both relaxation and entertaining, offering a peaceful retreat for summer cookouts, family gatherings, pets, playtime, or quiet evenings under the stars. With natural gas forced air heat, city water and sewer, a desirable neighborhood location, and many major updates already completed, this home offers a fantastic opportunity to build instant equity while enjoying comfortable living from day one. From summer nights in the backyard to winter evenings around the fireplace, this property is ready to welcome you home.

1303 Butternut Drive, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Mike Kelly and Sibcy Cline Inc.

$224,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 968506 MLS ⋅ Emilee Morris

This move-in ready property offers plenty of space and comfort, with features designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious family room is the perfect setting for family gatherings, movie nights, holidays, and creating lasting memories, while the additional living room provides even more flexibility for entertaining, relaxing, or creating a space tailored to your lifestyle. The home offers three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, providing plenty of convenience and functionality for both family and guests. Enjoy the welcoming large front porch, perfect for morning coffee, reading a good book, or visiting with neighbors. Out back, the large back porch overlooks a fully fenced-in yard, creating an ideal space for outdoor entertaining, relaxing, and enjoying time with family and friends. Plus, with a park nearby, you'll have an added opportunity to enjoy outdoor recreation and quality time with the family. Inside, the home has been thoughtfully refreshed with new paint (2026) and new flooring (2026), giving the entire space a clean, fresh, and inviting feel. A new roof installed (2023) provides additional peace of mind. With generous living space, functional amenities, and inviting indoor and outdoor areas, this New Carlisle home is ready to welcome its next family!

413 N Church Street, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Emilee Morris and BHHS Professional Realty

$204,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 968763 MLS ⋅ Joy Haynes

This home has recently been updated Siding ,Roof ,Kitchen ,windows interior doors and trim to name a few. Walk in shower. Larger ranch then most in the area with 1.1 Baths .Covered front patio And enclosed rear patio For your outside enjoyment storage shed .att 1 car garage

1738 Lundgren Road, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Joy Haynes and Howard Hanna Real Estate Serv

$149,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 966247 MLS ⋅ Arthur Solomon

Welcome to 223 Prentice Drive, a refreshed single-story home offering 2 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, and 1,075 square feet of flexible living space. LVP flooring flows throughout the main living areas and bedrooms, complemented by fresh neutral paint and plenty of natural light. The kitchen features select new cabinetry and an updated countertop, while a freestanding wood-burning stove with a stone surround creates a standout focal point in the open living area. The tiled bathroom includes a walk-in shower with a handheld showerhead and coordinated tile flooring and walls. A bright enclosed sunroom provides valuable bonus space for a home office, sitting room, hobbies, or entertaining, with a new sliding glass door leading directly to the fenced backyard. Additional features include vinyl siding, high-efficiency double-pane windows, new gutters, and an upgraded electrical panel. Built in 1955 on a 6,446-square-foot lot, this home combines practical updates, low-maintenance finishes, and useful additional living space in New Carlisle. The property has a large shed.

223 Prentice Drive, New Carlisle

Courtesy of Arthur Solomon and Coldwell Banker Heritage

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity program of the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than Real Estate Company are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2026 Dayton Area Board of Realtors®